Have you tried same experiment but locking the car only with the key, while sun is still up? If locked only with the key and no response on tugging, then, I would say microwave sensor is the culprit.
To be able to get to the sensor you need to remove t-bar. Problem is, in order to remove t-bar, you need to remove both seats.
I must have dreamt this one , as I have removed the Tbar on several occasions and have never removed the seats . There will be a how to on the forum for this .